A1 · Data and method
100-Point Scoring, Verification & Review Methodology
1. The 100-Point Capability & Telemetry Rubric
Every agency in the GridHue index is evaluated using the exact same four-pillar rubric combining reproducible first-party HTTP/DNS/DOM inspection with documented ecosystem credentials:
| Pillar | Max Weight | Measured Signals & Verification Formula |
|---|---|---|
| 01 · Technical & Security Hygiene | 40 pts | Clean HTTPS 200 resolution without redirect loops (10 pts), origin TTFB speed band up to 11 pts (≤200 ms = 11 pts; 201 to 450 ms = 8 pts; 451 to 800 ms = 5 pts), active Strict-Transport-Security HSTS header (7 pts), Content-Security-Policy or X-Content-Type-Options: nosniff headers (3 pts), and valid homepage application/ld+json structured data (9 pts). |
| 02 · AI Search & Machine Readability | 20 pts | Verified plain-text or Markdown /llms.txt endpoint at domain root excluding soft HTML 404s (11 pts), multi-entity Schema.org graph depth (up to 6 pts), and open crawler access for OAI-SearchBot, GPTBot, PerplexityBot, ClaudeBot, and Google-Extended in /robots.txt (3 pts). |
| 03 · Commercial & Pricing Clarity | 15 pts | Publicly linked /pricing/, /rates/, or package floor page on the flagship domain (15 pts), disclosed minimum project floor band (10 pts), or custom consultation scoping baseline (6 pts). |
| 04 · Ecosystem Credentials & Case Evidence | 25 pts | Verified platform partner tiers (WordPress VIP Gold/Silver, Automattic Pro Partner, Shopify Plus, Webflow Enterprise, Certified B Corp, Google Premier Partner), live /work or /case-studies documentation, and vetted client references. |
2. Three-Tier Agency Verification Framework
- Tier 1 · Live Domain Telemetry Verified: Passed automated brand-to-domain coherence checks, anti-hijack screening (filtering expired-domain redirects, casino/adult/pharma spam, and parked domains), and live HTTPS telemetry audit.
- Tier 2 · Corporate Domain Claimed: An executive or partner with an email address matching the agency's canonical domain has verified 2027 project minimums, hourly bands, team size, and B2B/B2C service percentages via Claim Profile.
- Tier 3 · Client Reference Verified: At least one external client with a verified non-conflicted corporate email domain has submitted a vetted multi-pillar engagement review via Submit a Client Review.
3. Client Review Verification & Anti-Gaming Protocol
Unlike unmoderated star-rating widgets, GridHue enforces three technical and editorial safeguards before any client review appears on an agency profile or emits Schema.org Review markup:
- Corporate Email Domain Gate: Consumer webmail addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, Proton, iCloud) are blocked at submission. Reviewers must authenticate with an active organizational domain.
- Automated Self-Review & Conflict Block: Any submission whose email domain matches the profiled agency's canonical domain (or subdomain) is rejected automatically at the API layer.
- Four-Dimension Numeric Rubric + Right of Reply: Reviewers score Quality, Schedule, Value, and Willingness to Refer (1 to 5), and profiled studios have a standing right of factual reply via our Editorial & Corrections Policy.
4. Open Reproducibility & Minimum Cohort Density
Anyone can verify an agency's live technical signals in real time using the Live Agency URL Grader or inspect the full 4,382-row CSV export. Category, country, regional, and city pages only unlock search indexation when five or more verified agencies pass audit in that cohort.